Revealed: The Forgotten Secrets of Stalingrad

Revealed: The Forgotten Secrets of Stalingrad

By: TONY PATERSON – November 2012


The date was 31 January, 1943. The place was the basement of the shell-shattered Univermag department store in the Soviet city of Stalingrad. And it wasn’t the forlorn and exhausted faces of the Nazis that stuck in the minds of the soldiers from the Soviet Red Army, as they opened the underground warren in which Adolf Hitler’s traumatised military commanders were hiding.

“The filth and human excrement and who knows what else was piled up waist high,” recalled Major Anatoly Zoldatov. “It stank beyond belief. There were two toilets and signs above them both read ‘No Russians allowed’.”

The legendary yet horrifically decisive battle of the same name had just ended in bitter and humiliating defeat for Hitler’s 6th Army. It was to be only a matter of time before Nazi Germany capitulated.

Lieutenant Colonel Leonid Vinokur was the first to spot the decorated commander of the German troops lying in a corner. “He lay on the bed when I entered. He lay there in a coat with his cap on. He had two-week-old stubble and seemed to have lost all courage,” he remembered. The commanding officer was Field Marshal Friedrich Paulus.

The graphic first-hand accounts of the Volga river battle which claimed the lives of 60,000 German troops and between half a million and a million Red Army soldiers are part of a collection of hitherto unseen interviews with Russian Stalingrad combatants which have been published for the first time.

The Stalingrad Protocols has been compiled by the German historian Jochen Hellbeck, who gained access to several thousand interviews with Second World War Red Army soldiers, held in archives at the Soviet Academy of Sciences in Moscow.

The accounts, which were originally intended as a record of the Soviet Union’s “Great Patriotic War” are so candid and disturbingly graphic that the Kremlin only published a small portion of them after 1945, preferring to opt for more orthodox Stalinist propaganda. The “protocols” languished in Moscow’s archives until 2008, when, acting on a tip-off, Mr Hellbeck was able to gain access to 10,000 pages of them.

The accounts suggest the invading German army’s murderous and brutal occupation of the Soviet Union was one of the prime motives behind the Red Army’s ferocious counter-offensive. A Soviet sniper called Vasily Zaytsev tells his interviewer: “One sees the young girls, the children who hang from trees in the park – this has a tremendous impact.”

Major Pyotr Zayonchovsky recalls finding the body of a dead Russian comrade who had been tortured by the Germans: “The skin and fingernails on his right hand had been completely torn off. The eye had been burnt out and he had a wound on his left temple made by a red-hot piece of iron. The right half of his face had been covered with a flammable liquid and ignited.”

The first-hand accounts also bring to life the terrifying ordeals suffered by both sides in the gruelling house-to-house street fighting which dominated much of the battle. In some cases the Red Army would find itself occupying one floor of a building while the Germans held another. “In this street fighting, hand grenades, machine guns, bayonets, knives and spades are used,” recalls Lieutenant General Chuikov. “They face each other and flail at each other. The Germans can’t take it.”

Historically, the protocols have been hailed as significant because they cast doubt on claims made by the Nazis and later by the Soviet Union’s Cold War opponents that the Red Army’s soldiers only fought so resolutely because they would otherwise have been executed by the Soviet secret police.

In his acclaimed 1998 account, Stalingrad, the British historian Anthony Beevor puts the number of Red Army soldiers executed by their own side during the battle at 13,000. He also points out that more than 50,000 Soviet citizens fought on the German side at Stalingrad alone. However, Soviet documents obtained during the compilation of the protocols suggest there were fewer than 300 executions by mid October 1942 – three and a half months before the German defeat.

Whether some of the interviews were given purely for Soviet propaganda purposes remains open to question. Those given by political officers suggest they played an important role in providing the inspiration to fight. There are accounts of them distributing leaflets during the height of battle depicting “the hero of the day”. Brigade Commissar Vasilyev recalls: “It was viewed as a disgrace if a Communist was not the first to lead the soldiers into battle.”

Hellbeck notes in his edition of the protocols that on the Soviet side at Stalingrad, the number of card-carrying Communist party members rose from 28,500 to 53,500 between August and October 1942 and that the Red Army saw itself as politically and morally superior to its Nazi opponent. “The Red Army was a political army,” he told Der Spiegel magazine.

Yet Stalingrad took a dreadful toll, even on the victorious Red Army heroes who managed to survive the Second World War’s bloodiest battle. Vasily Zaytsev who claimed to have shot dead 242 Germans, was the army’s top sniper. “You often have to remember and memory has a powerful impact,” he recalls one year afterwards, when the term post-traumatic stress disorder had not yet been invented. “Now I have unsteady nerves and I’m constantly shaking.” Other survivors of Stalingrad committed suicide years later.


Germany’s Last Surviving U-Boat Captain gets Modern Military Honour

Germany’s Last Surviving U-Boat Captain – decorated twice by Hitler for bravery after sinking 27 Allied ships – gets Modern Military Honour


Germany’s last surviving U-Boat captain who helped sink dozens of U.S. and British ships has been honoured by the modern military in his homeland seven decades after he was twice decorated by Hitler for bravery.

Reinhard Hardegen, 99, was one of the most successful commanders during Operation Drumbeat, when Nazi submarines attacked merchant ships along the east coast of North America.

Some 3.1 million tons of ships were sunk for the loss of 22 Nazi subs during seven months in 1942, which German commanders nicknamed the ‘American shooting season’.

Honoured: Reinhard Hardegen, 99, was one of the most successful commanders during Operation Drumbeat, when Nazi submarines attacked merchant ships along the east coast of North America.

It crippled the efforts by the U.S. to supply Britain with much-needed munitions.

Captain Hardegen personally oversaw the sinking of 27 Allied vessels – and it was for these actions that met Hitler for the second time to receive the oak leaves to his Knight’s Cross, Nazi Germany highest award for bravery. He already held an ordinary Knight’s Cross.

His submarine U123 was the most celebrated in the country, and because of his extraordinary courage he was awarded the coveted oak leaves to his Knight’s Cross during the war.

Reinhard Hardegen during the war.
Reinhard Hardegen during the war.

He wore the medal this week to celebrations in his native Bremen, which honoured his bravery in a service which saw the highest casualties of any in the war: 28,000 out of 40,000 crewmen never returned from their patrols.

On 31 July 1942, Hardegen left the submarine and became an instructor. In March 1943 he became chief of U-boat training in the torpedo school at Muerwik, and served for a few months in the torpedo weapon department.

Hardegen's submarine U123, pictured above, was the most celebrated in the country, with its captain personally oversaw the sinking of 27 Allied vessels.
Hardegen’s submarine U123, pictured above, was the most celebrated in the country, with its captain personally oversaw the sinking of 27 Allied vessels.

After the war, the submarine veteran spent more than a year in British captivity, before returning home in November 1946.

Speaking about Hitler presenting him with an award, he said: ‘Hitler pinned them to my jacket,’ he recalled.

‘I thought then he was a fine fellow.

‘That was a big mistake.

‘During Operation Drumbeat we were underwater for 14 days off the east coast of America when we surfaced.

‘In just under three weeks we sank seven ships with a tonnage of 46,744.’

He went on to build up a successful oil trading company, and was a member of Parliament in his hometown of Bremen for 32 years.

Hardegen travelled extensively in America, where he met men who had tried to kill him during his U-Boat service.

‘They are my friends to this day,’ he said.

The modern-day army in Germany honoured him for his wartime service at a barracks in Bremen.

Hardegen, who has four children, eight grandchildren and seven great grandchildren, has already reserved space in the town hall restaurant in Bremen for his 100th birthday next year.

Comrades: War correspondent Kriegsberichter Meisinger (right) and lieutenant commander Reinhard Hardegen (left) aboard the submarine U-123.


Reinhard Hardegen was a successful commander during Operation Drumbeat.

It was also known as The Second Happy Time or the American shooting season.

Between January and August 1942, U-Boats would attack merchant shipping along the east coast of North America.

It was named ‘happy time’ by German submariners because U.S defences were weak and the U-Boats were able to cause huge damage without much risk to themselves.

During this time, the German U-Boats sank 609 ships and lost just 22 U-Boats.

The U.S. response to Operation Drumbeat was slow, with many of those responsible for tackling the problem preoccupied with other battles – such as the Japanese onslaught in the Pacific.

Instead, the U.S government used secrecy and misleading propaganda to counteract public alarm at the sinkings.

The first U.S. Navy ship to sink a U-Boat off the American coast took place in April, 1942.


Update 6-25 : New Pictures Added to the Website


New Pictures have been added to the Website:

  • Individual Re-Enactment Impressions
  • Replica Uniforms made for Reenacting or Collecting
  • My Museum Collection of Memorabilia
  • Invasion of Poland
  • Battle of France – 1940
  • Battle of Britain
  • Operation Barbarossa – Invasion of the Soviet Union
  • Italian Front
  • Battle of Berlin
  • Other World War 2 Battles/ Major Events
  • December 44 Historical Museum – La Gleize, Belgium
  • Field Marshall Erwin Rommel
  • World War 2 Generals
  • Luftwaffe Officers
  • Fuhrer Adolf Hitler
  • HIAG Association meeting post-WW2.
  • WW2 Allies – Italy – Benito Mussolini

New Page has been Added to the Website:

  • Destruction of Germany During and After the War



Update 6-19 : New Pictures Added to the Website


New Pictures have been added to the Website:

  • Replica Uniforms made for Reenacting or Collecting
  • Re-Enacting and Events
  • Collections
  • Family Photos from the Wars of German History
  • My Museum Collection of Memorabilia
  • Movies
  • German Heer (Army)
  • Battle of Greece
  • Eastern Front
  • Italian Front
  • Other World War 2 Battles/ Major Events
  • Luftwaffe 1935-1946
  • December 44 Historical Museum – La Gleize, Belgium
  • Paintings & Art
  • Luftwaffe Pilots/Airmen
  • Bundeswehr
  • Leopard 2 – Modern Main Battle Tank
  • Bundeswehr Vehicles
  • Luftwaffe – After WW2
  • SS – Schutzstaffel

A New Page has been added to the website:

  • Models and Toys




Ferdinand and Elefant Tank Destroyer


Ferdinand and Elefant Tank Destroyer

by Thomas Anderson

This is the story of the largest and statistically most successful tank destroyer of World War II. The Ferdinand was a true behemoth, and although only 91 examples were built, they took a savage toll of Soviet armor in the Battle of Kursk and subsequent operations on the Eastern Front. This study explores the technical development and combat deployment of this remarkable vehicle, from its origins in the Porsche Tiger Tank through its deployment under the designation ‘Ferdinand’ in the Citadel offensive, to its modification and redesignation as the ‘Elefant’ and final use in the desperate Battle of Berlin. Drawing on original archival material from within Germany, private collections, and heretofore unpublished photographs this title is an essential illustrated history to one of the most famous armored vehicles ever built.



Survivors of Stalingrad: Eyewitness Accounts from the 6th Army, 1942-1943


Survivors of Stalingrad: Eyewitness Accounts from the 6th Army, 1942-1943

by Reinhold Busch

In November 1942 – in a devastating counter-attack from outside the city – Soviet forces smashed the German siege and encircled Stalingrad, trapping some 290,000 soldiers of the 6th Army inside. For almost three months, during the harshest part of the Russian winter, the German troops endured atrocious conditions. Freezing cold and reliant on dwindling food supplies from Luftwaffe air drops, thousands died from starvation, frostbite or infection if not from the fighting itself.
This important work reconstructs the grim fate of the 6th Army in full for the first time by examining the little-known story of the field hospitals and central dressing stations. The author has trawled through hundreds of previously unpublished reports, interviews, diaries and newspaper accounts to reveal the experiences of soldiers of all ranks, from simple soldiers to generals.

The book includes firsthand accounts of soldiers who were wounded or fell ill and were flown out of the encirclement; as well as those who fought to the bitter end and were taken prisoner by the Soviets. They reflect on the severity of the fighting, and reveal the slowly ebbing hopes for survival. Together they provide an illuminating and tragic portrait of the appalling events at Stalingrad.


Update 6-1 : New Pictures Added to the Website


New Pictures have been added to the Website:

• Movies
• Specialized Soldiers of World War II
• Operation Barbarossa – Invasion of the Soviet Union
• Tiger 1
• Panther
• Panzer IV
• Panzer III
• StuG III
• StuG IV
• Specialized Vehicles or Odd Devices and Equipment
• Rocket Weapons
• Weapons of WW2
• Focke-Wulf Fw 190
• Junkers Ju 87 Stuka Dive Bomber
• Luftwaffe 1935-1946
• Luftwaffe Pilots/Airmen
• Order of Battle – Waffen-SS Divisions



Largest Collection of Photos and Images of German History in the World with a focus on World War II.

%d bloggers like this: